Knights of Bay Shore Catering - Bay Shore, New York

Kelly S.

I had my daughter’s sweet sixteen there on Jan 26 2025. It was awesome. Sal worked within my budget to give my daughter the best night ever. Her friends and all the guests raved about the hall, the food and the service. Dennis and the rest of the staff were friendly ,pleasant and very professional. I would recommend this hall 100 percent.

Karen M.

Highly recommend the venue!
We held my mother's 90th Birthday Celebration here on 9/23 and it was wonderful! The staff was accommodating and helpful. Sal and Dennis were great through the whole process. All the servers at the event went out of their way to make sure the event was a success. The food was excellent and plentiful. Overall it was a wonderful experience and I would definitely plan an event there again.

Dallana F.

Highly recommend hosting your event here! Sal and the entire crew are seriously such amazing people. We celebrated our twin’s 1st birthday party this weekend and had the time of our lives. We did cater our own food but the service was excellent! They made our party as smooth as possible. Sal really worked with us and I can’t thank him enough for everything he did for us.

Minerva G.

I celebrated my 50th birthday yesterday, Feb. 24, I really had fun; the food was delicious , great for your event or party.

Alex M.

There is ample parking for one event but be mindful, with 2 levels this place often books simultaneous events that fill up the lot. The caterers provided food that was ok. The staff were polite enough but there are other venue with better pricing and quality

Kristina H.

We recently had our daughter’s 1st birthday at the Knights Of Columbus, (Bay Shore) and it was nothing short of awesome! Sal, the manager/event planner was VERY easy to work with and his staff was very efficient. The bartender, Dennis, made sure all of our guests were having a good time with the open bar. Marissa, our hostess/waitress always made sure we were doing great and our guests were taken care of. She set up the room to look very nice before the party and helped my family and I set things up beforehand, as well. Overall, all the staff working were happy, flexible and very accommodating throughout the whole party (especially with lots of little kids running around).

Best of all, and you honestly would not expect it, but the food was absolutely INCREDIBLE! People are still talking about how good the food was weeks later! We are looking forward to having another event here when the time comes. Thank you Sal and KOC!

Dave B.

Amazing venue, we had my Mother's surprise 75th Birthday party and the staff was super helpful, food was delicious and they accommodated all of our requests!!

Alan R.

My Wife's friends Birthday 50 year young great lady we had a great time the break dancers were sick great times as always